Agency scorecard · Methodology v1.0
Top Shelf Logic
Top Shelf Logic is a digital marketing agency providing fractional CMO services, SEO, paid advertising, and content strategy for law firms, home service companies, and e-commerce brands.
Preliminary score Based on signals we measure automatically: Google search position, Google reviews, a technical audit of this website and what the site itself publishes. Case studies, reviews on other platforms and other evidence raise the score once checked. Add evidence
Visit topshelflogic.com ↗Is this your agency? Claim the profile
Scorecard
- 01
Proof of results
× 25%18Not in the top 50 for its own city query; 3 case studies with measurable results, clients unnamed.
- 02
Client reviews
× 20%655 average from 31 Google reviews. Other platforms not yet verified.
- 03
Own-site technical quality
× 15%85Issues: no organisation schema (Core Web Vitals: lab test).
- 04
Transparency
× 15%60No published pricing, named team, address listed.
- 05
Demonstrated expertise
× 10%100Publishes articles, signed by named practitioners, mentions: Forbes Agency Council member, 3x Inc. 5000, featured on Diggity Marketing.
- 06
Longevity
× 10%21Founding year not stated; domain registered 2023.
- 07
Specialisation
× 5%40Generalist offer.
Total = Σ score × weight ÷ 100. How each criterion is measured.
Evidence ledger
7 items. “auto” = observed by our systems from the public source shown; anything not listed here did not count.
| Criterion | Claim | Source | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Demonstrated expertise | Forbes Agency Council member, 3x Inc. 5000, featured on Diggity Marketing | Agency website ↗ | auto · 2026-11-19 |
| Longevity | Domain registered 2023 | RDAP registry record ↗ | auto · 2026-11-19 |
| Proof of results | About $230K a week in sales on roughly $7K a week in spend, around a 33x return | Case study page ↗ | auto · 2026-11-19 |
| Proof of results | 70K+ organic clicks a month | Case study page ↗ | auto · 2026-11-19 |
| Proof of results | Top 3 local visibility for a law firm that started on page two | Case study page ↗ | auto · 2026-11-19 |
| Client reviews | 5 average from 31 reviews | Google Maps ↗ | auto · 2026-11-19 |
| Transparency | Team members named with roles | Team page ↗ | auto · 2026-11-19 |
Their own website, audited
5 of 7 checks passed · measured 2026-11-19 from our servers · domain registered 2023.
- ✓Largest Contentful Paint1.1 sGood ≤ 2.5 s
- ·Interaction to Next Paint—Good ≤ 200 ms
- ✓Cumulative Layout Shift0.00Good ≤ 0.10
- ✓HTTPSYesValid certificate
- ✓Indexable homepageYesNo noindex / blocks
- ✕Structured dataMissingJSON-LD on homepage
- ✓XML sitemapFoundDeclared or at /sitemap.xml