{"name":"Top Shelf Logic","website":"https://www.topshelflogic.com/","profile":"https://goodseocompanies.com/agency/top-shelf-logic/","methodology":"1.0","score":53.4,"scored_at":"2026-11-19","headquarters":"Dallas","founded":null,"criteria":[{"key":"results","label":"Proof of results","weight":25,"score":18,"why":"Not in the top 50 for its own city query; 3 case studies with measurable results, clients unnamed."},{"key":"reviews","label":"Client reviews","weight":20,"score":65,"why":"5 average from 31 Google reviews. Other platforms not yet verified."},{"key":"technical","label":"Own-site technical quality","weight":15,"score":85,"why":"Issues: no organisation schema (Core Web Vitals: lab test)."},{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","weight":15,"score":60,"why":"No published pricing, named team, address listed."},{"key":"expertise","label":"Demonstrated expertise","weight":10,"score":100,"why":"Publishes articles, signed by named practitioners, mentions: Forbes Agency Council member, 3x Inc. 5000, featured on Diggity Marketing."},{"key":"longevity","label":"Longevity","weight":10,"score":21,"why":"Founding year not stated; domain registered 2023."},{"key":"fit","label":"Specialisation","weight":5,"score":40,"why":"Generalist offer."}],"evidence":[{"criterion":"expertise","claim":"Forbes Agency Council member, 3x Inc. 5000, featured on Diggity Marketing","source":"https://www.topshelflogic.com/about-us","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"longevity","claim":"Domain registered 2023","source":"https://rdap.org/domain/topshelflogic.com","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"results","claim":"About $230K a week in sales on roughly $7K a week in spend, around a 33x return","source":"https://www.topshelflogic.com/case-studies","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"results","claim":"70K+ organic clicks a month","source":"https://www.topshelflogic.com/case-studies","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"results","claim":"Top 3 local visibility for a law firm that started on page two","source":"https://www.topshelflogic.com/case-studies","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"reviews","claim":"5 average from 31 reviews","source":"https://www.google.com/maps?cid=8166671128258694868","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"transparency","claim":"Team members named with roles","source":"https://www.topshelflogic.com/team","verified":"2026-11-19"}],"website_audit":{"checked_at":"2026-11-19T14:53:27.576Z","lcp_ms":1051,"cls":0,"inp_ms":null,"https":1,"indexable":1,"has_schema":0,"has_sitemap":1,"domain_created":"2023-02-22T14:19:30Z"}}