{"name":"Pilot Fish Media","website":"https://www.pilotfishmedia.com/","profile":"https://goodseocompanies.com/agency/pilot-fish-media/","methodology":"1.0","score":48.7,"scored_at":"2026-11-19","headquarters":"Edinburgh","founded":null,"criteria":[{"key":"results","label":"Proof of results","weight":25,"score":30,"why":"Not in the top 50 for its own city query; 2 case studies with measurable results."},{"key":"reviews","label":"Client reviews","weight":20,"score":32,"why":"4.4 average from 8 Google reviews. Other platforms not yet verified."},{"key":"technical","label":"Own-site technical quality","weight":15,"score":61,"why":"Issues: slow LCP, layout shift (Core Web Vitals: lab test)."},{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","weight":15,"score":35,"why":"No published pricing, team not named, address listed."},{"key":"expertise","label":"Demonstrated expertise","weight":10,"score":70,"why":"Publishes articles, signed by named practitioners."},{"key":"longevity","label":"Longevity","weight":10,"score":84,"why":"Founding year not stated; domain registered 2014."},{"key":"fit","label":"Specialisation","weight":5,"score":100,"why":"Focused on content."}],"evidence":[{"criterion":"longevity","claim":"Domain registered 2014","source":"https://rdap.org/domain/pilotfishmedia.com","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"results","claim":"Pickering's Gin: ROAS consistently over 5 for most campaigns and up to an incredible 14.8 for our abandon cart retargeting.","source":"https://www.pilotfishmedia.com/case-studies/","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"results","claim":"Shoppa: Acheived over 1000 downloads on the product in a couple of weeks.","source":"https://www.pilotfishmedia.com/case-studies/","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"reviews","claim":"4.4 average from 8 reviews","source":"https://www.google.com/maps?cid=18164417573671223500","verified":"2026-11-19"}],"website_audit":{"checked_at":"2026-11-19T14:50:26.940Z","lcp_ms":12171,"cls":0.3329283110571081,"inp_ms":null,"https":1,"indexable":1,"has_schema":1,"has_sitemap":1,"domain_created":"2014-05-10T17:38:15Z"}}