{"name":"Papaya Search","website":"https://papayasearch.com/","profile":"https://goodseocompanies.com/agency/papaya-search/","methodology":"1.0","score":54.5,"scored_at":"2026-11-19","headquarters":"Atlanta","founded":2004,"criteria":[{"key":"results","label":"Proof of results","weight":25,"score":30,"why":"Not in the top 50 for its own city query; 2 case studies with measurable results."},{"key":"reviews","label":"Client reviews","weight":20,"score":48,"why":"5 average from 12 Google reviews. Other platforms not yet verified."},{"key":"technical","label":"Own-site technical quality","weight":15,"score":81,"why":"Issues: slow LCP (Core Web Vitals: lab test)."},{"key":"transparency","label":"Transparency","weight":15,"score":60,"why":"No published pricing, named team, address listed."},{"key":"expertise","label":"Demonstrated expertise","weight":10,"score":30,"why":"Publishes articles, unsigned."},{"key":"longevity","label":"Longevity","weight":10,"score":100,"why":"Founded 2004; domain registered 2019."},{"key":"fit","label":"Specialisation","weight":5,"score":65,"why":"Focused on local, technical, content."}],"evidence":[{"criterion":"longevity","claim":"Domain registered 2019","source":"https://rdap.org/domain/papayasearch.com","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"longevity","claim":"Founded 2004","source":"https://papayasearch.com/about-us/","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"results","claim":"Tillamook Coast: 65% surge in organic search traffic","source":"https://papayasearch.com/case-studies/","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"results","claim":"Moonshine Post: first-page keyword visibility by 61%","source":"https://papayasearch.com/case-studies/","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"reviews","claim":"5 average from 12 reviews","source":"https://www.google.com/maps?cid=17982524981309689281","verified":"2026-11-19"},{"criterion":"transparency","claim":"Team members named with roles","source":"https://papayasearch.com/team/","verified":"2026-11-19"}],"website_audit":{"checked_at":"2026-11-19T14:47:05.187Z","lcp_ms":6151,"cls":0,"inp_ms":null,"https":1,"indexable":1,"has_schema":1,"has_sitemap":1,"domain_created":"2019-05-12T00:35:44Z"}}